Joseph Thomas Speaks At His Sentencing Hearing

Thomas tries to tell jury about his polygraph test but evidence was ruled inadmissible

Joseph Thomas -- -- spoke on his own behalf during his sentencing hearing Thursday morning.

Thomas talked briefly, less than a minute. Additionally, he did not do it under oath so prosecutors did not have a chance to cross examine him.

Thomas told the jurors that he had passed a polygraph test and another man had not. Yet the other man wasn't on trial, he said.

Assistant Lake County Prosecutor Charles Cichocki objected because the polygraph evidence had already been ruled inadmissible Wednesday by Lake County Court of Common Pleas Judge Richard Collins Jr.

Collins upheld the objection.

"The reliability of polygraph evidence has not sufficiently been established and, therefore, such evidence is not admissible in this case," Collins told the jury.

After talking about the polygraph test, Thomas added, "The rest of it -- that's for you all to decide I don't have to to say no more."

Thomas has been convicted of the rape, murder, kidnapping and aggravated robbery of McSween. He continues to insist that he is innocent.

However, the jury still has to deliver a verdict as to what his sentence should be.

The jury can choose a punishment between 25 years to life, other lengthier prison sentences or the death penalty.

To that end, Lake County Assistant Prosecutors Charles Cichocki and Pat Condon have presented aggravating evidence to justify the death sentence to the jurors.

Meanwhile, Thomas' attorneys -- David Doughten and Lake County Assistant Public Defender Charles Grieshammer -- offered mitigating evidence to justify giving a prison sentence.

Doughten and Grieshammer emphasized Thomas' difficult childhood.

Several family members and associates testified that Thomas .

The jury will begin deliberating on what Thomas' sentence should be today.

McSween, 49, was tending bar at Mario's Lakeway Lounge in Mentor-on-the-Lake on Nov. 26, 2010 and closed the bar by herself.

Thomas, who was at the bar that night, was arrested and charged with her death after authorities found McSween's burnt clothes in a barrel behind the Mentor-on-the-Lake home where he lived at the time of the murder.

More trial coverage:

Jury Begins Hearing Evidence in Joseph Thomas Murder Trial

Prosecutor: Clothes of Murder Victim Annie McSween Found in Suspect's Backyard

Patrons of Mario's Lakeway Lounge Testify About the Night Annie McSween was Murdered

Suspect's Neighbor Recalls Burn Barrel Incident Hours After Annie McSween Was Murdered

Jury Sees Police Interviews Of Murder Suspect Joseph Thomas

Ex-Girlfriends Of Suspect Testify At Trial

Defense Presents Its Witnesses At Joseph Thomas Trial

Witnesses Testify About Joseph Thomas' Childhood

(An editor's note: I apologize that the volume is so low in this video. I turned it up as high as possible.)

Karl Hubrath October 04, 2012 at 04:40 PM
People I have to say that I think there is something to Joseph passing the lie detector test, doubt. I have doubt on how he was able to pass the test. I think it is important to look at this test and to exclude it or reinforce it. I believe in lie detectors test if it is done right. I wonder if he answered the question of did you... with I do not remember. This may be the truth but not the truth, see? Alcoholics have black outs. If this were the case I doubt if anybody followed up with a question like " did you later remember ....?" I guess I would like to know and that it is also important to learn more about this lie detector test that Joseph took. God bless.
Jessica Cline October 04, 2012 at 06:09 PM
He could be a sociopath. Sociopaths can pass polygraphs even when they are lying. And as for the sob stories about his childhood, too damn bad. In my mind, the bad relationship with his mother actually furthers my belief that he would be capable of doing this to Annie McSween and if given the chance to other women. He should never be given the opportunity to do this to another human being.
Kacey Shea October 04, 2012 at 06:23 PM
Polygraphs are never admissable as evidence in a trial. They are brought up, but cannot be used to find someone guilty or not guilty. There are actually some sick people that can "pass" a polygraph while still having committed the crime.I really hope this sicko gets the death penalty, he deserves it.
Karl Hubrath October 05, 2012 at 08:41 PM
I agree with the SOB story part of your comment. We all had good times and bad times, however sometimes our reaction to a problem simply just creates a new problem. My personal thought and such hopes that polygraph tests are good. Wishful thinking, however I agree that maybe they are not a reliable test at all. God bless.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »